In September 2018, New York Penis Cakes was sold to Hope Jones of This Chick BakesNew York Penis Cakes was originally founded by Sarah. Sarah was searching for a bakery to provide an exotic cake for her friend's bachelorette party but ran into a bunch of problems in the process...not only was she embarrassed to call up local bakeries to ask if they made penis cakes, but it was also really inappropriate to do from her desk at work where coworkers could overhear. 

The limited options she found online either had terrible reviews, weren't able to deliver, or were located in far flung places outside of the range of the subway...mostly they just seemed sketchy. 

The result is New York Penis Cakes! A company committed to making the ordering process of your bachelorette party cake (or other occasion) simple, fun and easy while supporting local businesses and, most importantly, enjoying a scrumptious cake. 

As with This Chick Bake’s products, New York Penis Cakes products are made from the finest ingredients we can find. There are no Trans-fats, High fructose corn syrup (HFCS), artificial flavors or preservatives in any of our products. We use fresh ground peanut butter, Callebaut & Chocoa chocolates, organic teas, and pure extracts.*

“I only make stuff that we would like to eat!"  


Hope and her team at This Chick Bakes were the bakers behind the exotic cakes for many years, and have finally decided to come out of the closet as YOUR exotic baker!


Hope Jones Headshot.jpg

Hope Jones

CEO - Executive Baker